Mar, 23, 2012 By Vikram Murarka 0 comments
Most corporate risk managers refer to their hedges, such as forward contacts, as their "market position". They think that taking a hedge is the same as taking a trading position in the market. This is because taking a hedge is an act of volition, undertaken after due deliberation. Something is consciously done. The risk manager says he has taken a "market position". Further, there is a tendency to cancel and rebook forward contracts (something that has been curtailed by the RBI's Dec-11 guidelines), which has tended to give the hedge the flavour of a trading position.
However, this is incorrect. The hedge is not the company's actual market position. It is a transaction undertaken to offset, or square off, or negate, the actual underlying position that the company has in the market, as a result of its fundamental business transactions. See diagram 1.
If the Exporter now sells Dollars Forward for 3 months against this export receivable, he is hedging or closing out or squaring off his export receivable position. If the Dollar moves up against the Rupee, the gain on the exports is offset by the loss on the forward contract. On a net basis, therefore, the value of the Export Receivable is no longer exposed to market fluctuations. The position has been closed through the hedge, through the Forward Sale contract. See diagram 3.
Similar, but opposite is the position of the Importer, who is Short Dollars in the market by virtue of his imports. He has to buy Dollars in the market to make good his payment obligation. When he actually buys Forward Dollars, he is not taking a fresh position in the market. He is simply covering his exposure, providing for his payment obligation, squaring off the risk of Rupee depreciation.
Unfortunately, since the Risk Manager does not himself undertake the export or import transaction, or because the actually underlying position is created by default, there is a tendency to not recognize it for what it is, viz. the company's actual position in the currency market. It is unfortunate because this misunderstanding causes the company to ignore and overlook the profit or loss on its actual position and instead focus on the profit or loss of its hedge. This is akin to losing sight of the woods for the trees, because, usually, the quantum of the actual underlying exposure is greater than the quantum of the hedge.
Thus, when a hedge, whose quantum is, say, 30% of the actual underlying exposure, makes money, there is no reason to be overjoyed. Quite obviously, when the 30% hedge is making money, the balance 70% unhedged exposure is losing money. Similarly, if the 30% hedge loses money, that is no reason to crucify the risk manager - the balance 70% unhedged exposure is actually making money. In fact, therefore, if the hedge ratio is less than 50%, a loss making hedge is to be preferred to a profitable hedge.
In our last report (29-Jul-25, UST10Yr 4.42%) we expected the FED to remain on hold and said that since data was inconclusive the US10Yr was likely to be indecisively ranged in August, with a bit of …. Read More
The WTI Long-Short position (CFTC) has broken below multi-year lows and could now head towards the Oct-06 low of (1.13) indicating that Crude prices could continue to see … Read More
In our August 2025 outlook (dated 11-Aug-2025, EURUSD at 1.1623), we projected the Euro to strengthen towards 1.19–1.20 over the following months, before retreating to 1.14 by December 2025 and further easing to …. Read More
In our 10-Sep-25 report (10Yr GOI 6.48%) we expected the RBI to be on pause in its next MPC meeting on 01-Oct. This is to be seen tomorrow. We had also said there was room for the FOMC to cut rates by 25-50bp, and accordingly they … Read More
In our 08-Aug-25 report (USDJPY 147.24), we expected the USDJPY to initially fall to 145-144, followed by a consolidation between 144-152 till Feb-26 before eventually ascending towards 155. In actuality, the pair limited the downside to … Read More
Our September ’25 Dollar Rupee Monthly Forecast is now available. To order a PAID copy, please click here and take a trial of our service.