Investing - Where do we want to be right - Short Term or Long Term?

Aug, 27, 2013     By Vikram Murarka    0 comments


We invest to make profits, to multiply our money. Should we invest for the long term or for the short term? Would we want our investment decisions to be correct over the long term or in the short term?

Let us consider three cases.

Case 1 - Linear Growth

Let us consider a very simplistic case of linear growth over a period of time. If we consider a constant growth of Rs. 4 p.a. on a capital value of Rs. 100/-, we see that the graph is rising in a straight line at an angle of 45 degrees. Given the constant growth of Rs 4/- p.a. we get a return of 12% over a period of 3 years.

Linear GrowthCompared to this, the short term returns are 4% for the first year (being 104/100), 3.84% for the second year (being 108/104) and 3.70% for the third year (112/108).

This shows that staying invested over 3 years gives a total return of Rs 12/- or 12%, whereas staying invested for periods of 1 year only would give returns of Rs 4/- p.a. at a decreasing rate of return. A larger return on capital is obtained simply by virtue of remaining invested over a longer period of time, even though annual year-on-year growth is seen to be flagging with the passage of time.

Case 2 - Natural Growth Cycles

Natural Growth

Linear growth (blue line in the chart above) is not the way growth occurs in nature or in the business world. The Red Curve above is more in line with natural growth. This Red Curve can also be depicted by the Black Curve in the graph above.

Slow Growth

All plants, animals, humans and even companies grow in the manner depicted by the Black Curve, in three phases. In the first phase growth is slow in the early years (November 98 to March 03) followed by a sharp rise in growth in the second phase (between March 03 to July 07). Thereafter we notice a slowdown in the growth rate in the third phase in the later years.

Why does this happen?

  1. Initially a company takes to build its products and internal efficiencies. Capabilities are developed over time which bears fruits gradually.
  2. In the second phase, the company grows more rapidly as it builds a brand name and creates a market for its products/services to reach out to the consumers.
  3. In the third phase, growth slows down and follows a horizontal line over the later years as the old products become mature and the market gets saturated. The flat and steady growth continues till a point fresh product innovation takes place to foster a new growth phase.

Given that most businesses follow the growth path described above, it follows that an investor would want to buy into a young business and hold his investment through the early years of Growth Phase 1 so that he gets handsome returns in Growth Phase 2. It would be self defeating for an investor to exit the investment within just a couple of years after inception in frustration and impatience about the initially low returns. Investing in the business might appear to be a wrong decision in the short term, but it can appear to be a very wise decision in the long term.

This example shows that it is better to focus on being correct in the longer term.

Case 3 - Short-term fluctuations around long-term trend

Short Term Fluctuations

Breaking the long term chart into multiple small terms, we see that the price movement is volatile in the short term.

Ideally, profits could be maximized by buying at all the LOWs of the short-term chart and selling at all the HIGHs for every price fluctuation in the short-term. However, it is in a paradox in the investing and trading world that most people end up buying at the HIGHs and selling at LOWs.

The key to investing success is to notice that underlying all the short term fluctuations is a long term uptrend. That is the trend one should try to focus on. One should stay invested for the long-term instead of trying to buy low/ sell high along the short-term trend. The greatest danger with trying to be right in the short-term is that very often we tend to miss the woods for the trees. It may appear that, compared to some other people, one may have missed the opportunity to buy low/ sell high, but it is better to make that short-term trend rather than making the bigger mistake of missing the longer term trend.

Vikram Murarka

Chief Currency Strategist at KSHITIJ.COM. Likes to look at the markets from many different angles. Weaves many conventional and unconventional technical analysis techniques and fundamental analysis into a global macro perspective. Likes to take the road less traveled.



Leave a Reply


Dollar Rupee Forecast. Get a Free Trial

TWEETS


US-Japan 10Yr spread breaking support. Could it indicate further bearishness for USDJPY ? https://t.co/bgOpMKMsi1 https://t.co/bgOpMKMsi1

2 hours ago  

Yield Curve may actually steepen in the coming months as US Inflation is moving up, https://t.co/tg23YXPp5m https://t.co/tg23YXPp5m

1 days ago  

Crucial Resistance at 29000 on the #Sensex. Beware. Chances of good corrective fall. https://t.co/kzKSPRU7DR https://t.co/kzKSPRU7DR

4 days ago  

The German-US 2Yr has been giving cues of a fall in Euro for the past few days. https://t.co/CVyGv7PZ4U https://t.co/CVyGv7PZ4U

12 days ago